shimizudani withdrew by a foreign ship with his close retainers and escaped to aomori city . 清水谷は側近達を連れて異国船に乗船して撤退し、青森市へ落ちた。
he participated in the attack of the foreign ship in shimonoseki as the head of komyo-ji party lead by genzui kusaka . 久坂玄瑞が率いる光明寺党の党首として下関における外国船砲撃に参加した。
in the end , the three marquises including hisamitsu conceded to yoshinobu (bakufu ) and agreed to the foreign ship exclusion policy from yokohama port , but the discord between both parties was not settled , and the council of sanyo did not work well and was disorganized , leading to the setback of kobu gattai movement . 結果的に久光ら3侯が慶喜（幕府）側に譲歩し鎖港方針に合意したものの、両者の不和は解消されず、参預会議は機能不全に陥り解体、薩摩藩の推進した公武合体運動は頓挫する。
